Nationhood Means Nothing

Recently Paul Geddes, VP of the West Coast Libertarian Foundation, received a letter from the head of a writing group putting together a book to celebrate the 150th anniversary of Confederation next year. The general theme is “What is it to be a Canadian?” The writer was seeking input from various sectors of society including Canadian political parties. Paul received the letter as VP of the BC Libertarian Party.

No doubt the writer was expecting all sorts of mom and apple pie contributions – flag waving jingoism. I’m not sure how the writer will receive Paul’s contribution or if he will even use it. But it is, frankly, brilliant. Here it is for your consideration.

Nationhood Means Nothing

I reside in Canada (geographically) but not psychologically. I have close family members living on three continents under five national jurisdictions. If local satraps make my stay in this location too onerous, it will be costly, but I can move. My ancestors choose this jurisdiction to better their lives. If our officials make this location uncompetitive in the world market for talent, we (their descendants) will seek out better opportunities elsewhere.

I see calls for loyalty to Canada as nothing more than special interest groups making claims against my freedom, my earnings and/or my property. I do not understand why I should feel a sense of generosity towards those who just happen to reside in the same geographic location as me. I do not understand flag waving or the need to spoil sporting events with anthems to petty nationhood. I can understand the pleasures of local art, but don’t see how adding a nation’s name to such adds any value. I see “Canada” as a man-made artificial division of parts of us from the rest of mankind. It consists of barriers to trade and communication and makes those stuck within its borders poorer and less free than we need be.

I have a picture on my wall of the gravestone of a great uncle who gave up his life (as near as I can tell from his letters) for God and King (WWI) I often wonder what his death accomplished and how alien he would feel about Canada today. Those pictures of acres of similar gravestones, should make you pause and wonder about the wisdom of following the dictates of national leaders.

In short, I look forward to a future without border guards. Where I don’t have to respond to nosy bureaucrats asking me my business or confiscating my purchases. Where being Canadian is just a fact about birth in a particular location, meaning nothing more.

Paul Geddes, Vice President , BC Libertarian Party

Libertarianism and Growing Up

One of my lefty friends recently posted this meme on Facebook. The meme originated with Occupy Seattle. growinguplibertarian


The meme implies that libertarianism is immature and growing up means giving up such childish notions. In fact, the truth is the complete opposite. Statism and growing up are incompatible. Growing up means to become a libertarian.

The essence of libertarianism, and its great appeal, is non-violence. Libertarianism advocates a society where the use of force and fraud are barred from human relationships. A society where all interactions are peaceful and voluntary. It is a society where adult individuals are self-responsible. It is a society where reason and argument replace fisticuffs and violence.

Statism, on the other hand, advocates the use of force to get otherwise peaceful individuals to kowtow to the will of others, those in government, because they know better.  Statism is okay with using coercion and compulsion to force people to do things the statist believes he should do because it is for his own good.

Let’s take a very simple example, seat belts. Seat belts are a great invention. Undoubtedly they have saved many lives. I use my seat belt all the time. I consider it folly not to.

That said, as a libertarian, I consider it none of my business whether you or anyone else wears a seat belt. It is a private decision that should be left to adult individuals to decide for themselves.

The statist, on the other hand, favours laws making seat belt use mandatory. They favour using the apparatus of coercion and compulsion to force people to wear seat belts whether they want to or not. They do so because, like parents, they feel the need to treat people like children.

Now growing up entails several things. It means we give up having our mommies and daddies making decisions for us and learning to make our own decisions, even if we sometimes make mistakes in the process. It means learning to live peacefully with other people, settling disputes by discussion and rational persuasion, not by force like the bully in the school yard. It means becoming self-sustaining individuals, finding productive work so we can supply ourselves with food and shelter.

As a child, all these things are decided for us by our parents and teachers. Our parents curb behaviour they believe may be destructive to self or others. They compel behaviour they believe is for our own good, such as eating our vegetables or wearing a seat belt. Food and shelter are provided by our parents until we are grown up and ready to leave home to become autonomous individuals.

But for the statist, children do not grow up. They must remain forever children with the state taking the place of the parents. Rightfully, the state does intervene when force or fraud are used. It is acting as an agency of self-defense for the victim of aggression. But, unfortunately, the state does not limit itself to a self-defense function when it is run by statists.

The statist mentality is that most people are too stupid to be autonomous individuals. They must be treated like children. If they don’t want to use their seat belts, then, by God, we’ll compel them to do so with a threat of punishment if they don’t comply. If they don’t want to eat healthy food, then, by God, we will ban super-size drinks in theaters or put a tax on junk food.

The adult in a statist society is treated like a child. He is not allowed to grow up. The adult in a libertarian society, on the other hand, is treated as an adult, encouraged to make decisions and make his way in the world.

Here is the meme revised to be truthful.growingupstatist